On August 11, 2025, a startling incident unfolded in the South China Sea: a Chinese coast guard cutter and a Chinese Navy destroyer collided while chasing a Philippine Coast Guard vessel near the disputed Scarborough Shoal (also known as Panatag Shoal or Bajo de Masinloc). The confrontation was captured on video and released by the Philippine Coast Guard, intensifying regional tensions and drawing global attention to the volatile maritime disputes in the area.
Business Insider
The Times of India
The Incident: What Exactly Happened
High-Speed Pursuit and Sudden Crash
In videos captured by the Filipinos, the BRP Suluan, a Philippine Coast Guard multi-role response vessel, was escorting aid to fishing vessels when it was aggressively pursued by a Chinese Coast Guard cutter, identified as CCG 3104. The cutter deployed water cannons and closed in at high speed. Suddenly, CCG 3104 executed a sharp maneuver originating from the starboard quarter of the Philippine vessel and collided with a larger Chinese Navy destroyer, hull number 164.
Business Insider
OneNews.PH
Maritime Executive
Damage Assessment
The impact severely damaged the forecastle (bow) of the coast guard cutter, effectively rendering it “unseaworthy.” The Navy ship also sustained visible dents and scratches. Philippine officials emphasized that despite offers of assistance for rescue or medical aid, the Chinese vessels did not respond.
Business Insider
OneNews.PH
New York Post
Baird Maritime / Work Boat World
Straight Arrow News
Strategic and Regional Context
Scarborough Shoal: Regional Flashpoint
Scarborough Shoal lies within the Philippines’ Exclusive Economic Zone but has been under effective Chinese control since 2012. Manila won an international arbitration ruling in 2016 invalidating China’s sweeping claims, but Beijing has continued to deploy coast guard and maritime militia forces in the area. The shoal remains a frequent site for confrontations over fishing rights and territorial claims.
Philstar
The Times
Pattern of Maritime Confrontations
This incident builds upon a troubling pattern of aggressive encounters in the West Philippine Sea. Water cannon usage, laser threats, and repeated blocking and ramming by Chinese vessels have been reported near disputed maritime areas like Second Thomas Shoal and Sabina Shoal.
Wikipedia
+2
Wikipedia
+2
AP News
Wall Street Journal
Reactions and Diplomatic Fallout
Philippine Response
The Philippines condemned the collision as reckless and dangerous, with Coast Guard spokesman Commodore Jay Tarriela calling for adherence to the COLREGs—the international regulations for preventing collisions at sea. The Department of National Defense called China’s behavior “atrocious and inane.” President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. reiterated the country’s resolve to continue asserting its sovereignty in the region.
Business Insider
The Times of India
New York Post
AP News
Chinese Reaction (or Lack Thereof)
Beijing’s official comment did not acknowledge the collision. Instead, it reiterated that their coast guard took “lawful and necessary measures” to drive away what they characterized as a “Philippine intrusion” near Scarborough Shoal. This omission has drawn criticism from Manila and international observers.
Business Insider
South China Morning Post
Newsweek
Greater Implications and Strategic Analysis
Operational Risks and Escalation
The collision underscores how aggressive maritime operations—even involving vessels of the same country—can backfire. It reveals the risk of accidents amid high-pressure confrontations and underscores the importance of professional navigation, proper coordination, and de-escalation, especially in disputed zones.
Philippines’ Transparency Initiative
Manila’s aggressive public documentation of the collision reflects its broader transparency initiative—a policy of actively publicizing clashes with China’s maritime forces to garner international support and deter further aggression.
Wikipedia
Geopolitical Ripples
The incident underscores that tensions over maritime claims can intersect with global geopolitical fault lines, such as rising concerns about conflict involving Taiwan. President Marcos highlighted that due to proximity and the presence of hundreds of thousands of Filipino citizens, the Philippines could get drawn into a broader regional conflict.
AP News
Conclusion
The dramatic collision between two Chinese vessels during a pursuit of a Philippine Coast Guard ship highlights the hazards of maritime brinkmanship in contested waters. It was not just a risky maneuver—it symbolized broader geopolitical tensions playing out across the South China Sea. The incident reinforces the need for adherence to international maritime norms, transparency, and diplomatic restraint. As tensions persist, this event serves as a vivid reminder of how quickly maritime disputes can escalate—and how preventive measures are desperately needed to avoid unintended consequences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- What exactly occurred during the incident?
During a maritime standoff near Scarborough Shoal on August 11, 2025, a Chinese coast guard cutter (CCG 3104) collided with a Chinese Navy destroyer (hull 164) while pursuing a Philippine Coast Guard vessel, the BRP Suluan.
Business Insider
OneNews.PH
Maritime Executive - What damage did the collision cause?
The coast guard cutter’s forecastle was severely damaged, making it unfit for navigation. The naval destroyer also sustained dents and scratches.
Business Insider
Baird Maritime / Work Boat World
New York Post - How did the Philippines respond?
Philippine officials condemned the incident, urging China to follow international navigation rules (COLREGs). Secretary of Defense called the actions “atrocious and inane,” while President Marcos vowed to continue asserting maritime rights.
Business Insider
The Times of India
AP News - Did China acknowledge the collision?
No. Chinese authorities confirmed a maritime encounter but did not mention the collision. They characterized the incident as a legitimate enforcement of territorial claims.
South China Morning Post
Newsweek - Why is Scarborough Shoal such a flashpoint?
Scarborough Shoal is located within the Philippines’ Economic Exclusion Zone but has been controlled by China since 2012. Although a 2016 international ruling invalidated China’s expansive claims, Beijing continues to enforce its presence, leading to recurring confrontations.
Philstar
The Times